All posts tagged trash

Winner of the tallest snowman in the city competition

Published January 16, 2018 by justicewg
8 ft tall snowman

I call it, Mt Freeze Megasnowman, the Comprehensive Community Driven Facility Finance Committee crusher

Years ago my kids and I built this 8 ft tall snowman. The city of Grandview Heights just ran a snowman competition, and didn’t specify the dates for the snowman building, it just had to be in this city. We won! We deserved it too, almost broke my back getting that second snowball up on top.

Congratulation to the kids who won in other categories. Just don’t try to top my snowman – no really, don’t try, it would be dangerous to do it. Make your dad build a bigger snowman!


Khouzam agrees that taking discarded stuff from the alley is legal

Published March 6, 2016 by justicewg

Xmas TrashmanI wanted to have a definitive answer on the issue of taking discarded stuff from the alley. Officer Cohill was not really clear on how this works as far as ownership of discards and what the police would do when they saw a resident taking something from the alley. The matter was referred to City Attorney Khouzam, and she gave me the final word on how the matter will be dealt with in Grandview.


Mr. Wagner:

The police department forwarded me your inquiry regarding the city’s trash removal ordinances, and the regulation to determine when permits should be issued.  That regulation was to permit the city to ensure safety and reduce theft/unauthorized removal of materials, particularly at a time when metals were being stolen and turned in to fabricators and recyclers for cash. 

The City’s ordinances provide for authorized removal by city personnel of items placed in collection bins or bags, or otherwise bundled and left in the right of way where bins and bags are placed.  As indicated by the year of passage and the reference in the first line, Codified Ordinance 955.06 was intended to prohibit hauling companies from engaging in the business of collecting, hauling or transporting waste (i.e., doing so for a fee), since the city provides this service at no additional charge to residents.  The ordinance addresses persons in the business of” performing such services.  This provision should not be read as an invitation to trespass onto residents’ private property.  When in doubt, it is recommended that a homeowner be asked whether he/she actually intended for item(s) left at the curb to be repurposed by others.

Taking your example, if a neighbor leaves a picture frame or a piece of furniture on the right of way, a person not “in the business” of waste removal can take what is in the right of way, other than bins, bags, or bundles (city has exclusive province to do this).  If the person removing the frame or furniture happens to be driving a truck that would suggest he or she is in the business of hauling, then the city has the ability to act on this accordingly.  Of course, as you know, the city provides an annual free hauling week in approximately mid-May, when it removes far more than bins, bags, or bundles. 

The city has not initiated criminal actions against residents who remove items left at the curb by homeowners.  However, the city has had occasion to intercept unauthorized persons attempting to remove property from lawns, property that was not intended for discard or removal, or persons with trucks full of “salvaged” goods.  As a result of the police department’s and our residents’ vigilance in that respect, theft and unauthorized removal have declined. 

Thank you for your inquiry, and I trust this will address your concern.

Joëlle Khouzam, City Attorney

Ms Khouzam;

Thanks for the answers to my questions about removal of materials from alleys set out for the trash.

The one questions I would like clarified is the distinction you made between picking up material with a truck, and the possible use of a car or van. If I saw a large set of shelves set out by my neighbors down the street, I would not have the strength to carry it back to my house, so I would want to use my van to transport it.

You said that “If the person removing the frame or furniture happens to be driving a truck that would suggest he or she is in the business of hauling, then the city has the ability to act on this accordingly.”

Would the use of my van also be considered a business vehicle, and then would be used to charge me with a violation of Ordinance 955.06? Is the kind of vehicle used while moving items from the alley what defines a violation of the law?

Or is it the stated use of the items that are removed? If I say to any police officer who stopped me. “I am removing this item for my own personal use, and have no business or financial gain in taking it, I’m
doing it for my hobby”.

Is a statement of non-commercial use all that is needed to remain in compliance with Ordinance 955.06? – JW

I used the word “truck” by way of illustration.  If a police officer has reason to believe a business is being conducted by someone picking up curb items, whether the person is driving a truck, car, or SUV, I am confident he or she will intelligently inquire and discern whether the person is just repurposing shelves for their own use or if it’s someone who’s in it for commercial gain.  The person’s intent, not type of vehicle, governs whether further action is warranted.

Just for peace of mind, please know that our officers do not make a practice of questioning residents who stop when a neighbor has set out furniture or other items on the curb.  The matters that have resulted in charges typically involve people who are hauling anything and everything left outside, even when it’s not in the right of way and particularly metal items.

Joëlle Khouzam

Thanks to City Attorney Khouzam for the definitive word on the issue. I’m sure that most Grandview residents don’t really care about the rules and will continue to pick up the neighbor’s picture frame from the alley without knowing anything about the laws. Those who care enough to look into it will now know that you can’t get a ticket in the unlikely event a cop was watching you in your alley.

Previously –

The standard arguments against taking stuff from alleys

Who owns the trash in alleys?

The standard arguments against taking stuff from alleys

Published February 26, 2016 by justicewg

Xmas TrashmanI have some answers from the city on the questions I had about the rules for removing junk that was set out for trash pickup. I’ll get to that in a later post, first some discussion on the whole trash issue.

The three R’s – reduce, reuse and recycle. It is taught to little kids in school, it is the mantra of anyone who cares about the problems we have in a society that wastes too much, worships new stuff when old versions are still working, and is filling the dump sites to overflowing. All of the R’s are not simple to do, reusing is especially problematic for people who don’t want to use Craigslist, and find it simpler to set still good material out by the trash.

I’ve read a lot of online wrangling over taking discarded stuff, if you want to see some people flipping out, just search for the comments that get posted whenever Freegans are mentioned. The less extreme practices of people who just pick a few choice items sitting out by trash cans can also cause the heebie-jeebies in certain types. In order to preempt some of the arguments that occur over and over when this issue is discussed, I’m going to do a brief summary of the past discussion.

The xenophobe (also known as The Trump)

This person has a fear based response. “The hordes of poor people will come into our little city and strip it bare! We must defend it from all trespassers!”

The xenophobe has an over-developed defense reaction to what is a minor problem. I can’t provide statistics for an issue which occurs out of sight for most people, with no consequences. But I would guess there is only a tiny number of people who do scrapping in alleys who also steal stuff. After all, you are placing a big obvious sign on yourself when you have scrap metals into the back of your truck, the police have no questions about what you are doing. Only the dumbest of thieves would think it was a good plan to steal stuff then continue to drive around with the stolen material in full view.

All the discussion and worries about scrappers are out of date. The prices of scrap metals have bottomed out, there is no money to be made by scrappers anymore. Maybe prices will go back up, but for now this discussion is moot – you will not see scrappers when it costs more in gas than can be earned by scouring alleys.

Bad news for recyclers too, the city’s recycling program cost the city about $20 a ton to have it taken away. Regular trash cost $40 a ton to have it taken to the dump, so it makes financial sense for the city to recycle, it just isn’t putting us in the plus column (these numbers per Director of Administration Patrik Bowman).

Read the rest of this entry →

Who owns the trash in alleys?

Published January 12, 2016 by justicewg

Xmas TrashmanYou’re taking the trash out early one morning on the way to work. Across the alley you notice a nice picture frame set out beside your neighbor’s trash can. You walk over and check it out – nice condition, clean, the picture is nothing you want but the frame will fit perfectly in your living room with a new photo. You begin to walk back to your house, when suddenly a blinding light comes from a car you didn’t notice rolling up the alley. A loud voice comes from the police car.

“Sir, please stop. You are in violation of Grandview Ordinance 955.06 . Put the frame on the ground and place your hands behind your head!”

Could that happen in Grandview? I’m not sure if you can be arrested for picking items out of the alleys, but you certainly can be ticketed by the Grandview cops. Every couple months there is a story in the TVN police beat where people are ticketed “for removing material from alleys without a permit”. I wondered – what is the real deal on this law, can the city really make it illegal to remove trash – which was headed to packer trucks, then shredding and the landfill? Who owns stuff that is thrown away? Wouldn’t it be better for this stuff to be used by anyone who wanted it, or recycled for the value of the materials? And what is the “permit “ that is mentioned in the news stories, who gives these permits out?

Taking broken electronics from alleys

I have written about the topic of junk in the alleys before, please read this old post for more on why this issues is something I care about.

I have a more selfish reason to care about junk in the alleys, I belong to a small and nerdy group of people who look for old electronics equipment, do repairs, and use this old stuff. Watch this video from a YouTube guy who is well known for fixing discarded equipment.

My own attempts to learn electronic repair have been limited by a shortage of old electronics to practice on. Nobody tries to sell the old stuff on Craigslist, they either sell working equipment that is a few years old (for too much money), or they throw the old stuff in the trash. I have found a few treasures in the past, but I am limited in looking in the area around my house, I don’t want to have to explain to police officers why I want that old radio that is sitting on top of a trash can.

I asked for information from the Grandview police – exactly what ordinance is used to ticket people who take stuff out of the trash? How does one get a permit?

Official reply from Grandview Police

I asked the police chief some questions about the laws covering removal of trash from the alleys in Grandview, this is what I was emailed.

My name is Officer Janna Cohill with the Grandview Heights Police Department. I’m our Public Information Officer if you have any future questions.  The ordinance is 955.06-Private Collection Restricted, and it is posted under the Streets, Utilities, and Public Service Codes. I will attach a copy of the ordinance to this email.

The police department started enforcing the ordinance approximately five years ago, because we noticed that many of the people driving through to “scrap” were also committing crimes, such as, theft and criminal trespass. The thefts included items in residential yards, open garages and construction material that were obviously not scrap or trash. This ordinance assisted with monitoring our alley ways and combating crime in our city.

As far as obtaining a permit for this, the Mayor has the authority to issue them, but I do not believe he is approving any at this time.


Officer Janna Cohill

This is the ordinance that was attached to the email.


After January 1, 1955, no person, firm, or corporation shall engage in the business of collecting, hauling, or transporting along or over the streets, alleys, or public ways of the City and garbage except as is provided for by this chapter.

(Ord 63-54. Passed 12-6-54)

The obvious question this information provokes – it says you can not “engage in the business of collecting”. But if you are just a Grandview resident taking a picture frame leaning against the neighbor’s trash can, you are not engaged in any sort of business. How can this ordinance apply to you?

What the internet says about taking trash from alleys

I found a number of online legal resources, all of them said that it is not illegal to take something that has been thrown away, and that discarded items are in the public domain. You can’t trespass, you can’t take things that are not clearly trash, you can’t make a mess while looking in the alley, but it is not illegal to take discarded items.

The highest law in the land, the Supreme Court, made a decision in 1988 called California v. Greenwood that is the final words on the ownership of trash. From the website:

“CALIFORNIA v. GREENWOOD, 486 U.S. 35 (1988) stemmed from a 1984 investigation in Laguna Beach, Calif. Investigators suspected Billy Greenwood of drug trafficking and found evidence in his curbside trash. The evidence enabled them to obtain a full search warrant of his house which lead to his arrest, but charges were dropped because of the unwarranted search of his trash citing fourth amendment rights.

In California v. Greenwood, the Supreme Court ended up ruling in favor of investigators and held that “the Fourth Amendment does not prohibit the warrantless search and seizure of garbage left for collection outside the curtilage of a home.”

Because the police want the right to go through trash looking for evidence of crime, the Supreme Court has ruled that all trash is public domain. Anyone who wants it can take it, police or private citizen.

If you are uneasy about the though of either police or snoopy neighbors looking in your trash can, understand this – your trash has always been a weak security spot, no matter what the laws say. If you throw important paperwork out without shredding, if you toss computer equipment away without wiping the hard drives, you have set yourself up for identity theft. It is your responsibility to keep vital information secure, so that nobody can use it. This is identity theft prevention 101, it has been hammered in the news reports about identity security, and by police who are trying to stop this crime.

Even if Grandview could make it illegal to take items from the alley, where do you think that stuff goes after it leaves the trash trucks? Do you think the people who work further down the trash pipe have security clearances?

Grandview considers the law as written

After I asked further questions about the ownership of discarded trash and the city ordinance, I was told that more consideration is needed.

I’ll be posting more on the questions about this issue. Stay tuned.

Previously – Junkman in the alley

Junkman in the alley, part two

The final word on taking junk from the alley –

Khouzam agrees that taking discarded stuff from the alley is legal

Junkman in the alley, part two

Published December 18, 2012 by justicewg


I’m cleaning out the basement, so I can start the new year with less clutter. Today I had another encounter with a junkman in the alley.

This time I had an old print dryer to discard, along with other metal crap, and I posted the stuff on the “free” section of Columbus Craigslist. It took about 30 minutes for the first replies to come in.

I met the guy in the alley, he was driving an old beat up van that was emitting a small cloud of steam from some leak in the system. He had a sad story that he told as he was looking at my old truck covered in a tarp, he said he used to own a garage and did restoration on old vehicles. The set of tools needed to do that sort of restoration work is considerable, so he must have been in much better financial shape in years past. He said he lost his job, the garage, all the tools. It didn’t sound like he had much left except the old van and a phone that allowed him to check the CL listings for scrap.

His wife was with him, and she noticed I had a bag of old toys set out. She was very grateful when I said she could take them too, she said this Christmas would be lean for her kids, so anything, even old toys from the alley, would be appreciated.

I know what you are thinking – those people are giving you a sad story in the hopes of getting some charity. They probably make a good living, tax free!

If they were pulling a fake sob story, they were doing a convincing job of it. Everything I saw told me they were desperately poor people who really needed every cent they could get from scrapping in alleys.

Grandview doesn’t allow junkmen to roam the alleys in the city, they can face a hefty fine if they are caught. If you post a message offering stuff and people come to pick it up, it would not be illegal.

My suggestion to anyone who will be throwing out good sized metal junk is to take the time to make a post on Craigslist in the “free” section. You don’t have to meet the scary poor people when they come to pick the stuff up, you can just tell them to get it from the alley by themselves. The metal will be recycled, instead of clogging up the lanfill, so it is the environmentally correct thing to do. And, quite possibly, the people who pick the stuff up will be really poor people who will be able to scrape another day’s worth of food and rent out of the stuff you will be tossing away.

( Junkman in the Alley pt 1)

(Who owns the trash in alleys?)

Junkman in the alley (from G.W.)

Published December 20, 2011 by justicewg

Another re-post from the old blog. I had a guy come to my door today and ask if he could have an old tall computer I had set in the alley. I asked him if he had been hassled by the police, he said no, but he had not been in this town much. I’ve read a lot of stories in the police beat about junkers being ticketed because they didn’t have a permit to pick through the alley. I’m going to have to investigate this new trash picker licensing, how much it costs, why they did it, etc.

Read the rest of this entry →